Scroll to Top

Assessment

Office of Institutional Effectiveness & Evaluation Texas A&M University Office of InstitutionalEffectiveness & Evaluation

Manual & Requirements

Final Report - Compliance Indicators

At the end of each Program Assessment cycle, OIEE staff review all Assessment Reports and assign a Compliance Indicator (CI). CIs are simply meant to inform Program Coordinators and unit leadership of how well documentation requirements were met. OIEE uses the rubric below to assign Compliance Indicators. Qualitative feedback may also be provided. 

Rating CategoryCriteria
Exemplary
The report goes beyond minimum requirements. This generally includes the following:
  • There is more than one measure for each outcome.
  • Thorough, detailed descriptions of each section—data collection methods, data analysis, scoring metrics, rubrics, etc.—are included so that the assessment process is replicable.
  • Findings are contextualized, and (if applicable) are appropriately disaggregated by location and/or student subgroup.
  • The use of results is clear, detailed, and focused on improving the unit’s services for the student subgroups it serves.
Sufficient
All minimum requirements are met. For example:
  • Each outcome has at least one measure, and all measures are aligned with their respective outcomes.
  • The report is clear overall. Some areas could be strengthened by including more detail.
  • The use of results is focused on unit improvement. The planned execution may not be fully clear, but the intent is.
Needs Improvement
All minimum requirements are met, but one or more of the following is true:
  • The assessment process is difficult to follow and may not be clearly replicable.
  • Components of the report may be misaligned (e.g., the measure does not align with the outcome).
  • Findings may not be disaggregated (i.e., by location and/or student subgroup, if relevant).
  • The use of results may not be focused on improvement of the unit (e.g., a change to assessment plan and/or scheduling a meeting to discuss results). The use of results may not be clearly tied to findings or may not address one or more of the noted student subgroups.
Noncompliant
Report was not submitted, or one or more required components of the report is missing (outcome, measure, findings statements, and/or use of results). The report does not demonstrate the unit's commitment to continuous improvement. 
Manual & Requirements
...